Join this community!
› Share page: Email Digg del.icio.us Reddit icon StumbleUpon Technorati
Go
Search posts:

Confused About Soy?

Posted Oct 01 2008 8:24pm 3 Comments
A recent post (6/22/06) reported on a study confirming the benefits of soy and heart health. But it seems not everyone agrees. For some, the jury is still out, according to some reports on WebMD.

I like soy milk and use it in shakes and, combined with nonfat milk, I pour it over oat cereal. I like the way it tastes. However, soy contains a specific estrogen-like compound, daidzein (which appears to be responsible for some positive effects of soy on cholesterol levels in women, one study shows).

But estrogen! Some guys hear the word estrogen and red flags go up. If I eat soy will I grow breasts? Another fear is that it can diminish one's libido. Enough! Enough! What is true? Is soy a miracle food that some experts have claimed or something to be avoided? My guess is that it falls somewhere between the two extremes.

Most of the scientific information that I have found casts soy in a positive light. But maybe it has been oversold as a miracle food and its benefits exaggerated. I certainly wouldn't use it to the exclusion of other sources, but soy remains on my own list of healthful protein. So far, I haven't developed female characteristics, my libido is just fine, and my cholesterol levels are right where they belong.

Any thoughts you'd like to share? Click on "comments."

To learn the latest on what the doctors are saying about soy, go
here.
Comments (3)
Sort by: Newest first | Oldest first

Hello, Does this mean that you dismiss all the research carried out by Kaayla Daniels as documented in her book "The Whole Soy Story" and reject the 'SOY Alert" brochure information as circulated by the Weston Price Foundation?

FredCB

I think we have a case of dueling research conclusions. For example, I can cite Loma Linda University Hospital studies (such as http://lomalindahealth.org/health-library/a-z-health-guide/1/007204.htm) that negate Weston Price, etc. And we could go back and forth. Then it becomes a question of which research/studies are of the higher quality. Until convinced otherwise, I stand by what I wrote in "Confused About Soy." Here is what I would urge anyone making dietary changes to do when confused: Go to their personal physician and just say "Hey, Doc, I've been reading good things and bad things about soy products. What do you think?"
Hi LoganF.  Does not the question of vested interests come into the matter of research findings? Who stands to gain the most? Who is doing the funding? Why should I think that a personal physician is any better informed when it comes to resolving the confusion where conflicting information is involved. Are not most physicians schooled in conventional thought and under the sway and pull of big pharmaceutical companies? Mind you I have an open mind on this matter, but remain skeptical? Why? Well I was always under the impression that SOY was a beneficial health food. Hence for many years consumed the product driven by this understanding. In particular lecithin; a tablespoon with breakfast every morning. Is it a co-incidence that after years of doing this, almost 10 years ago my libido was completely lost.  I wonder, after recently reading that SOY products were taken by Monks for the very purpose of curtailing libido. Your comments seem to indicate that you would be in head-on conflict with Elaine Hollingsworth, Director of the Hippocrates Health Centre Australia, Author of the book titled 'Take Control of Your Health and Escape the Sickness Industry. Related WEB page being www.doctorsaredangerous.com The section in her book headed 'SOY - the Abominable Bean' gives much food for thought. Incidently, are you saying that Kaayla Daniel's research is not to be trusted?  Have you written to her and queried her findings? Thank you for hearing me out. Fred CB
Post a comment
Write a comment: